Volume 15, Number 33, August 5, 2012
Click here to read this issue on the web
To comment or submit articles, reply to email@example.com
WAYNE'S WORDS: THE E-SYLUM AUGUST 5, 2012
New subscribers this week include Robert Baglier and Francisco E. Latorre. Welcome aboard! We have 1,577 email subscribers, plus 185 followers on Facebook.
This week we open with a reminder of the NBS events at the ANA convention, as well as updates from numismatic dealers planning to attend. Next up is a new book announcement and a book review from John and Nancy Wilson.
Other topics include a new medal of Honor Museum, the Battle Born collection of Carson City coinage, and several recipients of ANA awards. To learn more about a new Noah's Ark coin, Hurricane Hugh, a curiously engaved 1840-O Half Dollar and the mint in heathen territory, read on. Have a great week, everyone!
NBS EVENTS AT THE 2012 PHILADELPHIA ANA CONVENTION
Just a reminder about events at this week's American Numismatic Association show in Philadelphia. Enjoy, everyone! -Editor
The Numismatic Bibliomania Society's 2012 Symposium (Thursday 11:30 a.m.-1:00 p.m., Room 106AB, Philadelphia Convention Center) will be a panel discussion:
"Numismatic auction catalogs from various perspectives": David Fanning, dealer in used & rare numismatic literature at Kolbe & Fanning Numismatic Booksellers
Scott Rubin, collector & independent researcher (consultant to PCGS CoinFacts)
RyAnne Scott, ANA Library and Communication Director
Alan Stahl, curator of numismatics at Princeton University Numismatic Collection and cataloger for Paul Bosco Coins.
Vicken Yegparian, cataloger and vice-president of numismatics at Stacks Bowers.
The Numismatic Bibliomania Society's General Meeting (open to all) will be held Friday, August 10, 11:30 a.m.-1:00 p.m., in room 106AB of the Philadelphia Convention Center. In addition to being the annual business meeting for NBS, it will also include a discussion on "The Challenges and future of Numismatic Publishing" with Steve Roach (editor of Coin World) and Kerry Wetterstrom (editor & publisher of The Celator) and an auction of donated literature lots to benefit NBS.
To read the NBS web site events page, see: www.coinbooks.org/events/
To read the ANA's page for NBS events, see:
NUMISMATIC LITERATURE DEALERS AT THE 2012 ANA CONVENTION
Numismatic literature dealers will be out in force at this week's ANA convention. David Fanning forwarded this note. -Editor
Kolbe & Fanning Numismatic Booksellers will be set up at the ANA's World's Fair of Money, August 7-11 in Philadelphia. Our booth number has changed and is different than what will be listed in the program. Our booth number is 1521. Please stop by and browse our selection of fine numismatic books, including rare plated auction catalogues, out-of-print standard references and important foundational works.
Highlights include finely bound copies of James Mease's 1834 work on American medals and his 1838 work on American coins (which Eric Newman has called "the first numismatic article on American coins published in America"). Other items include two original copies of Crosby, one featuring the rare Woodburytype plate of Dr. Maris, the other ex Armand Champa; a set of Rizzo on Sicily; plated Chapman sales including Jenks, Bement (American) and Warner; the Bathe book on Jacob Perkins; classic works on ancient coins, etc. Stop by Booth 1521 and check it all out!
David F. Fanning, Ph.D.
Kolbe & Fanning Numismatic Booksellers LLC
David Sklow forwarded this note about this week's ANA convention. -Editor
I will be attending the American Numismatic Association Convention in Philadelphia August 5-11, 2012. Have me paged, or check the exhibit area, if you would like to sit down and talk about Numismatic Literature. Also Mail Bid Sale # 17 closing Saturday October 6th, 2012 is now on line at our web site.
David Sklow-Fine Numismatic Books
Charlie Davis will be there, too. He sent this note. -Editor
I will be at ANA Philadelphia at tables 88-90.
Tel: (978) 468 2933
NEW BOOK: HALF CENT QUICKFINDER, 2ND EDITION
Greg Heim forwarded this announcement of the second edition of his Quickfinder" guide to U.S. Half Cents. -Editor
After 15 years, I am pleased to announce the second edition of my Half Cent Quickfinder for attributing die varieties. I am unofficially calling the project "QF2!"
Despite the fact that no new varieties have been discovered since 1997, a lot has changed with regards to the business strike issues of United States Half Cents. Technology and 15 years of experience have allowed me to streamline this work, and most importantly to increase the efficacy of the logical flow.
The old book was 64 pages. This one will be about 20 pages shorter. The format will be exactly the same: 5 1/2 X 8 1/2 format, black and white, and printed on a nice quality paper stock.
I will be at the ANA Convention to take pre-orders for the book. I am doing a small run of 250 copies to start. I am still toying what I am going to charge within a few dollars, but I will know by the time I leave. Also, I will have something set up on my website when I get back from the convention.
Greg's website is www.njcoinbuyer.com and his e-mail is firstname.lastname@example.org . -Editor
BOOK REVIEW: A GUIDE BOOK OF MORGAN SILVER DOLLARS, 4TH EDITION
John and Nancy Wilson submitted this review of the new edition of Dave Bowers' book on Morgan silver dollars. Thanks! -Editor
A Guide Book of Morgan Silver Dollars, A Complete History and Price Guide, 4th Edition/Updated and Revised, 2012, The Official Red Book, By: Q. David Bowers, Foreword by Leroy Van Allen,
The book is soft cover with 304 pages. Mr. Bowers is no stranger to silver dollars having authored previous editions of this reference, hundreds of articles and in 1992 the two-volume study “Silver Dollars and Trade Dollars of the United States: A Complete Encyclopedia,” which is still the standard in the field. We Americans love to collect Morgan silver dollars! No other coin conjures up so much of the romance and adventure of the United States.
Chapter 1 “The Appeal and Challenge of Morgan Dollars.” The chapter gives a historical perspective about the discovery of vast quantities of silver in the West which led to the Bland-Allison Act of 1878. The Treasury Release following the rise in the value of silver in the 1960s and the redemption of silver certificates for silver and later silver dollars from the treasury hoard accumulated in the 1800s.
Chapter 2 “The Tradition of Silver Dollars.” This chapter covers from the Spanish milled dollar through the Gobrecht Silver Dollars, Liberty Seated Silver Dollars, Trade Dollars and the realities of the silver bullion market.
Chapter 3 “Designing the Morgan Dollar.” The Mint Director, Henry R. Linderman, was more interested in getting the coins into production and he didn’t wait for the designs and dies to be properly completed and reviewed which resulted in the many varieties of the 1878 Morgan Dollar. It is interesting to note the mint director was a numismatist and owned an 1804 dollar.
Chapter 4 “Minting Process.” All the steps from the making of the die to its hardening are explained. The actual making of the coin from processing the planchets as well as the packing and storing of the coins is also explained.
Chapter 5 “The Five Morgan Silver Dollar Mints.” A brief history of each of the five mints is given.
Chapter 6 “Treasury Hoards and Other Quantities.” The cash window in Washington D.C. is covered along with some of the many stories about some of the silver dollars it released including Liberty Seated dollars, Carson City dollars and Lafayette dollars. In 1962 the cash window started releasing some formerly rare dollars and the rush was on.
Chapter 7 “Ways to Collect Morgan Silver Dollars.” Along with collecting the dollars by date and mintmark, which makes for a large collection, it explains collecting by reverse types, mints only, or patterns.
Chapter 8 “Grading and the Marketplace.” Dave Bowers explains the history of grading systems and has photos of coins in all the grades. Evaluating sharpness along with differences between semi-prooflike to DMPL (Deep Mirror Proof Like) is covered. The chapter ends with information on buying coins – ordering coins by mail, buying in stores, coin shows and bidding and buying in auctions.
Chapter 9 “Beyond the Basics: Specialized Varieties.” The first significant die research as well as Howard R. Newcomb’s The Numismatist 1922 editorial which is reprinted along with other thoughts by him on the subject. Francis Klaes 1963 publication of a pamphlet and Neil Shafer’s 1964 review in the Whitman Numismatic Journal are also reviewed regarding Silver Dollars. Known Die Varieties in the Comprehensive Catalogue and Encyclopedia of Morgan and Peace Dollars by Leroy C. Van Allen and A. George Mallis; and the Michael S. Fey, PhD and Jeff Oxman reference The Top 100 Morgan Dollar Varieties: The Vam Keys (Third Edition).
Chapter 10 “Year by Year: An Analysis by Date and Mintmark.” The 163 pages closing out this chapter is the bread and butter of the reference. Most of them will have optimal collecting grade; circulation-strike and proof mintages; key to collecting circulation strikes; surface quality; proof like coins; mintage and distribution; die varieties; mintage, and key to collecting proofs. The Whitman Coin Guide at the bottom of each page has grades from VG-8 to PF-67. Availability in Certified and DMPL will also have grades along with photos of the issues and close-up detail on some.
Appendix A “Morgan Silver Dollar Patterns.” This short section shows photos and information on the Judd patterns along with auction records.
Appendix B “Misstruck and Error Morgan Dollars.” Photos of error coins are shown and how they occurred is explained.
The Glossary, Notes and Bibliography close out this well written and researched reference.
It is another in the long line of references by the Dean of Numismatics, Q. David Bowers, and we highly recommend it for your library. For information on purchasing this book which retails for $19.95, you can contact: Whitman Publishing, LLC, 3101 Clairmont Road, Suite G, Atlanta, GA 30329, Phone No. (800) 546-2995 or visit their web page at, www.whitmanbooks.com
NEW MEDAL OF HONOR MUSEUM PLANNED IN CHARLESTON
Charleston, S.C. is set to be the home of a new $100 million museum devoted to medal of Honor honorees. -Editor
Standing on the hangar deck of the World War II aircraft carrier Yorktown, officials with the Patriots Point Naval and Maritime Museum announced plans Wednesday for a $100 million Medal of Honor Museum honoring the recipients of the nation’s highest award for valor.
The museum on high ground on Charleston Harbor would replace a smaller one aboard the carrier and make Patriots Point a national destination, said Ray Chandler, the chairman of the Patriots Point Development Authority.
The authority has signed a letter of understanding with the Congressional Medal of Honor Society to build a museum “honoring the highest heroes of this country,” he said.
Retired Maj. Gen. James Livingston, a South Carolina recipient of the medal, wants to move quickly.
“This is the final opportunity to establish a lasting legacy for the Medal of Honor while we still have recipients alive from World War II, Korea, Vietnam and the War on Terror,” he said.
Livingston, who is on the organizing committee for the foundation, said of the 3,456 recipients of the honor, only 81 are still living. Their average age is 73. He said it is fitting for Charleston to be the location for the new museum. The Medal of Honor was established during the Civil War, which began with the bombardment of Fort Sumter on Charleston Harbor.
A master plan for the museum released Wednesday envisions, among other attractions, a uniform collection, a large format theater with multiple video screens where visitors can learn about sacrifices for freedom, a Great Hall honoring the medal recipients and an interactive media gallery where visitors can hear each recipient’s story.
To read the complete article, see: Charleston plans $100 million Medal of Honor Museum (www.thestate.com/2012/08/02/2379265/charleston-plans-100-million-medal.html#.UB7vIU1lTIg)
A visitor looks at a display at the Medal of Honor Museum
aboard the aircraft carrier USS Yorktown
The project is expected to cost more than $100 million. In addition, the museum will be supported by a multi-million dollar hospitality and consumer component that will feature a world-class destination hotel with amenities, including a conference center.
“We fully expect that this project will serve as a catalyst for additional investments at Patriots Point,” Chandler stated. “This will include both cultural and appropriate commercial and hospitality uses of the highest quality.” It is estimated that by the third year of its operation, the National Medal of Honor Museum will attract more than 200,000 visitors per year.
To read the complete article, see: Patriots Point selected as site of National Medal of Honor Museum (www.artdaily.org/index.asp?int_sec=2&int_new=56939#.UB6gcE1lTIg)
MORE ON SRI LANKAN NUMISMATICS
Regarding Katie de Silva's report on her visit to Sri Lanka, Kavan Ratnatunga offers these notes. Thanks! -Editor
That note of featured previously in E-sylum in 22 Nov 2009 See www.coinbooks.org/esylum_v12n47a24.html .
There are few nicer numismatic packs sold by the Central Bank of Sri Lanka www.cbsl.gov.lk/htm/english/13_cart/products.asp .
The numismatic collection at the Colombo National Museum and the Central Bank Museum are nice to visit. There are also some nice coins on display at the Dutch Period Museum.in Pettah I don't remember the collection in Kandy.
If any numismatist is visiting Lanka please contact me at Kavanr@gmail.com I will love to meet, and maybe if you are in Colombo on the 3rd Sunday of the month attend a meeting of the Sri Lanka Numismatic Society
See also http://coins.lakdiva.org .
Sri Lanka’s expatriate population is the second largest in the world in per capita population terms, next only to Lebanon;
To read the earlier E-Sylum article, see: KATIE DE SILVA'S SRI LANKA REPORT (www.coinbooks.org/esylum_v15n32a13.html)
NOTES FROM E-SYLUM READERS: AUGUST 5, 2012
First Coins of the New Year
For many years, I have noted the day I receive the first coin of the new year, cent or no. Not including the Statehood quarters, the earliest I ever got a new year coin in change was January 15, 1972. It was an Ike dollar.
To read the earlier E-Sylum article, see: CHARMING CUSTOM: FIND FIRST CENT OF THE NEW YEAR (www.coinbooks.org/esylum_v15n32a17.html)
Chopmark Collectors Club Dues
When the Chopmark Collectors Club was re-vitalized and the Chopmark News was re-established, the dues were indeed zero, but now if you get a mailed copy of the newsletter, there is a charge. Those who get it via email are assessed no dues. The hard copy costs from $10-$25/year depending in the kind of production you want and the delivery option chosen (air or sea). It comes from Taiwan.
I confirmed this with Chopmark News editor Colin Gullberg who writes:
Yes, the information is correct. Subscriptions cost $10 - 25 depending [on type of subscription], e-editions are currently free. Donations are encouraged.
To read the earlier E-Sylum article, see: THE CHOPMARK COLLECTORS CLUB (www.coinbooks.org/esylum_v15n32a12.html)
Armenia's New Noah's Ark Coin
END OF RESEARCH TRAIL FOR LINCOLN MEDALIST BYRON M. PICKETT
Dick Johnson submitted this account of a numismatic research project involving sculptor Byron M. Pickett. -Editor
This numismatic research adventure started for me as I cataloged the medals for Medallic Art Company in the late 1960s. One of the medals the firm had made was a Lincoln Medal for the Lincoln National Life Insurance Company struck in 1963.
The Insurance company had sponsored a museum of Lincoln items since 1926. One of their acquisitions was a Lincoln Plaque issued in 1908 by a promoter I.G. Muller of a Lincoln bas-relief made in 1873. Muller identified the Lincoln portrait only as "Pickett Head." And that is all the museum knew.
On one of my research trips to the New York Public Library I searched the art division's card catalog (remember card catalogs old-timers?). I found a Pickett with two items in an 1873 auction catalog. It listed the artist's name and a two-word lot description: "Florence--Medallion." Further search located no other Pickett.
I wrote the Lincoln Museum Director, R. Gerald McMurtry. He assured me this was the correct artist. "Perhaps, you have made an important discovery in finding a reference to Byron M. Pickett." he wrote.
Five years later on a family trip west we stopped in Fort Wayne to visit Kenneth Hallenbeck, now past ANA president (and father of present ANA president, Thomas G. Hallenbeck). I reported this in an E-Sylum article (vol 11, no 11, article 12) where I related that my family slept in the Hallenbeck driveway (actually in a motor home). Ken was an employee of the Insurance company and he agreed to introduce me to the museum director the next day.
At the museum I saw a card below the Pickett Head on exhibit and quickly copied down the data. This Pickett Head, the data revealed, was the source of the design for two U.S. Postal Cards issued 1911 to 1917. I researched this further and wrote an article in Linn's Stamp News 24 March 1980. This was rewritten for an article in Postal Stationery (May-June 1980).
Fast forward to 2006. It was one of those articles that attracted the attention of Ron Haney of Rochester New York. Ron is a great grand-nephew of Pickett and was seeking data on his relative when he stumbled on my article. He wrote and we began an active email correspondence. I was as eager to learn about Byron M. Pickett as an artist as Ron was as active learning of a predecessor. I immediately sent Ron the listing I had on Pickett in my American Artists Databank.
I recognized his eager interest and in 2008 sent him a packet of all the material I had in my Pickett file, including photos: of the 1873 Lincoln bas-relief plaque, Muller's plaque, Medallic Art Company medal struck in 1963, a 1966 calendar published by the Insurance Company with the Lincoln Medal illustrated on the cover, even a calendar card for the year 1966.
Plus, of course, photocopies of that 1873 auction catalog, a Lincoln Lore publication on the Picket Head plaque, and a photocopy of a page from a Manhattan New York guidebook illustrating the Samuel F.B. Morse Statue, which was Pickett's most famed work of art.
Ron's research continued. He kept me in the loop, and sent copies of each new Pickett item discovered. It was a delight to open each new email.
This week I received the latest -- the capstone of Pickett research. Ron had learned where Pickett was buried, but had no headstone. He ordered one listing both Bryon and wife Ella, and had it installed in place at the Brookside Cemetery in Tenafly, New Jersey.
Byron Pickett's Samuel F.B. Morse statue
A local newspaper ran this article August 5:
American sculptor Byron M. Pickett is memorialized
To read the earlier E-Sylum article, see: LARGEST LINCOLN NUMISMATIC COLLECTION IN LIMB (www.coinbooks.org/esylum_v11n11a12.html)
CARSON CITY COIN COLLECTION ARTICLES
There was quite a bit of publicity recently surrounding the "Battle Born" collection of Carson City coins being sold this week. Here's an excerpt from an article that appeared in USA Today August 1st. -Editor
Add up their face value, and the 111 rare coins in the "Battle Born Collection" amount to under $600.
But throw in their lure to coin enthusiasts - each struck in the Carson City Mint between 1870 and 1893 with the most prized coin the only known 1873 "No Arrows" Seated Liberty dime to exist - and the price tag soars.
Their owner, an anonymous Nevadan, could earn $11 million-$15 million at auction next week in Philadelphia, and a Reno coin dealer assisting him in the process says it will be a once-in-a-lifetime event.
"This is my Olympic moment," Rusty Goe, owner of Southgate Coins, said Tuesday of the upcoming sale, part of the Rarities Night Auction at the American Numismatic Association's World's Fair of Money Convention. "This is the biggest event that's ever happened to me in my 30-year career as a coin collector."
Goe serves as a paid consultant to the collection's owner, whom Goe refers to only as "Mr. Battle Born" after Nevada's state motto.
Until the coins are sold individually at auction, they remain the only complete collection of coins made in the Carson City Mint, Goe said. They represent each of the 111 different date-and-denomination combinations issued from the Mint before it closed in 1893 in what is now the home of the Nevada State Museum.
The auction's success could be affected by potential buyers' confidence at the moment with market conditions, Goe said, adding, "We just won't know for sure until then. We'll see how close we come to our pre-sale estimates."
Either way, Goe hopes to use the event as a showcase for Nevada and the Carson City Mint's opening at the height of the Comstock Lode era.
He's already convinced Stack's Bowers Galleries of Irvine, Calif., which will put on the auction, to print a separate catalog on the Battle Born Collection in addition to the main publication for participants.
He also said a bit of historic irony has not been lost: The Philadelphia Mint, the nation's first opened in 1792, opposed creating a Carson City branch when the issue was debated in Congress in the 1860s.
"They said, why do we want to put a mint in that heathen territory, a Wild West area like that? So for this one night, Carson City will steal the show from the Philadelphia Mint," he said.
To read the complete article, see: Rare Carson City coins going to auction (www.usatoday.com/news/nation/story/2012-08-01/rare-carson-city-coins/56647974/1)
The original article is from the Reno Gazette-Journal, which had more and better photos. -Editor
To read the complete article, see:
'Battle Born:' Rare Carson Mint coins going to auction on Philadelphia stage
QUERY: AN ENGRAVED 1840-O HALF DOLLAR
The August 2012 issue of The E-Gobrecht, the electronic newsletter of the Liberty Seated Collectors Club, pictured an interesting engraver 1840-O Half Dollar. Here are the images and accompanying text. Can anyone help? -Editor
Club member Brian Greer sent in an interesting 1840-O half dollar (imaged below). It is a WB- 13, a rare variety. On first appearance, it is a very nice original XF coin but close observation shows hand engraving on the reverse. The engraving says “13.244 grams” which appears to be contemporary. Assuming it to be the weight of the coin, I weighed the half dollar with my modern digital scale and came up with 13.24 grams! Indeed, it is the weight of the coin.
Now for the hard part, other than to prove the weight of the coin for some reason, why would you want to weigh and annotate this commonly (then!) circulating half dollar. Think about it and send your comments to the E-Gobrecht editor.
The E-Gobrecht editor is Bill Bugert, and he can be reached at email@example.com -Editor
ANNA HYATT HUNTINGTON'S 1943 AFRICAN ANIMALS MEDAL
My wife likes elephants, so I thought I'd share this delightful medal by Anna Hyatt Huntington from Joe Levine's July 28, 2012 email Token and Medal Mini Fixed Price List. Below are the image and description. Joe can be reached at JLevine968@aol.com. -Editor
AFRICAN ANIMALS, 1943. A: SOM-27. Golden Bronze. Edge B. 73mm. Bronze. Anna Hyatt
Huntington, Sc. (MACO). Uncirculated. With scattered dark spots on both sides. The obverse bears an imposing view of an African elephant plodding through the jungle grass, while the reverse depicts a variety of African wildlife at a water hole.
This was the 27h issue of the Society of Medalists. It is one of the few medals in the series to which there is not “story” attached. Mrs. Huntington states, “African animals and their great variety of form and color are an unending source of delight to the animalier and personally, I am always happy when I can get the excuse to work on them, so this composition was done from a selfish point of view to amuse myself.”
Apparently, collectors have also be “amused” by this delightful medal as it is one of the most popular in the series. Original box and descriptive pamphlet. $210.00
You can't order this one, though - I bought it! -Editor
THE BOOK BAZARRE
ROBERT W. JULIAN NAMED ANA'S 2012 NUMISMATIST OF THE YEAR
The American Numismatic Association has announced that its 2012 Numismatist of the Year Award will go to Robert W. Julian. It's hard to think of someone more deserving - congratulations! Below is an excerpt from the ANA's press release, follow by part of an article in CoinWeek. -Editor
Robert W. Julian has been named the American Numismatic Association’s 2012 Numismatist of the Year. Julian will receive his award on Aug. 10 during the Awards Banquet at the ANA World’s Fair of Money in Philadelphia.
A researcher and prolific, award-winning author, Julian is perhaps best known for his quintessential work Medals of the United States Mint: The First Century, 1792-1892, published in 1977. Other books include From Rus to Revolution: Russian Coins through a Thousand Years (1988); Medals of the United States Assay Commission, 1869-1977 (1989); and Russian Silver Coinage, 1796-1917 (1993).
To Julian, coins speak volumes—about history, economics and American culture. “I gain satisfaction from finding new and interesting information about coins and medals that has remained unpublished or little known,” he said. “As I study documents in the National Archives, I have the sense of being at the writers’ sides as they pen U.S. Mint history into the dusty ledgers.”
“(Julian’s) first publication was an article on the coinage of Czar Alexander II that appeared in Numismatic Scrapbook in 1960. Since then, he has published more than 1,300 articles in all the significant commercial and organizational numismatic publications in the United States and some overseas,” said Joseph E. Boling, who nominated Julian for the award. “He has spent hundreds of hours at the National Archives, extracting information that he then passes to the collecting community. His carefully researched treatises, most based on primary sources, have changed our common knowledge.”
CoinWeek published a nice interview with Julian by Al Doyle. Here's an excerpt. -Editor
He’s one of those semi-familiar names who has accomplished as much or more in his field than others with greater notoriety. That’s what happens when a person quietly and diligently goes about his business for more than half a century.
Author and researcher R.W. “Bob” Julian will be honored as the American Numismatic Association‘s Numismatist of the Year during the upcoming ANA summer convention in Philadelphia. Julian’s byline has been a regular sight in coin publications since the early 1960s, and he can do more than write magazine-length articles.
Medals of the United States Mint – The First Century is still regarded as a “must read” book 35 years after its 1977 publication by the Token and Medal Society. It was the product of thorough research and an unwavering commitment to accuracy. In other words, a typical Julian effort.
“I spent 12 or 13 weeks at the National Archives in 1975 and 1976 doing research for the book,” Julian said. “My first visit to the National Archives was in 1963. You soon learn that your hand wears out taking notes, so I started using a reel to reel tape recorder.”
Like many who grew up in the 1950s, Julian’s interest in coins was sparked by checking dates on Lincoln cents. The Logansport, Ind. native quickly moved on to a much different area of numismatics.
“There was a local coin dealer, and I would go to his shop,” Julian recalls. “He had trouble identifying his foreign coins, so I did it. There was no pay involved, but I would receive five or 10 coins out of every lot for my work. The czarist Russian coins looked neat, so I started collecting them.”
The interest in Russian coinage has never waned. Julian’s term paper on Russian monetary reform in the 1800s caught the attention of a professor at Purdue University.
“The professor liked it so much that he recommended I try and get the paper published,” Julian said. That led to a number of articles on Russian coins for the Numismatic Scrapbook and The Numismatist.
His hunger for knowledge and verifiable information was evident even at a young age. Julian corresponded with the Hermitage in Leningrad (now St. Petersburg) in an effort to learn more about Russian coinage. That was an unusual move during the height of the Cold War era.
The Hermitage’s staff numismatist offered to microfilm Russian-language numismatic books. The cost was $100, a significant sum at a time when a new car could be purchased for $2000. Julian came up with the cash.
“I can read Russian slowly and catch snippets of conversation,” he said. “It’s all self taught.” Speaking of teaching, Julian made his living as a math teacher in Logansport for 30 years and spent much of his free time in numismatic research and writing.
“Nobody gets rich writing articles, but I just enjoy finding new material and publishing it,” he said. A good chunk of Julian’s earnings as a coin writer were used to feed his quest for knowledge, and that led to a problem which required a creative solution.
“There’s a little home I bought and fixed up to keep my library of 5000 to 7000 books,” Julian said. The converted home also serves as his office. Although he doesn’t keep track of the hours spent on writing and research, it’s much more than a casual pastime for the retired teacher.
Now THAT'S a numismatic library! The CoinWeek article mentions that Bob is working on a book dealing with the history and operations of the Philadelphia Mint prior to 1837. -Editor
To read the complete article, see: MEET THE 2012 NUMISMATIST OF THE YEAR (www.coinweek.com/people-in-the-news/meet-the-2012-numismatist-of-the-year/)
DAVID E. SCHENKMAN TO RECEIVE LIFETIME ACHIEVEMENT AWARD
There will be many awards given at this week's ANA convention, but another one of note is the Lifetime Achievement Award. The 2012 honor deservingly goes to E-Sylum regular Dave Schenkman. ANA Library & Communications Director RyAnne Scott forwarded the press release - here's an excerpt, along with a photo of Dave speaking at the 2011 meeting of the Numismatic Bibliomania Society. -Editor
Author and Summer Seminar instructor David E. Schenkman will receive the American Numismatic Association’s Lifetime Achievement Award on Aug. 10 during the World’s Fair of Money in Philadelphia.
Schenkman has shared his knowledge of tokens with collectors since his first article was published in 1964. Every one of his eight books is considered a standard reference. He has been a columnist and contributing editor for The Numismatist for many years and won an ANA Heath Literary Award in 1994.
He edited the Token and Medal Society publications for 27 years, the Civil War Token Society journal for five years, and he served as president of both clubs. Schenkman also is a member of the American Vecturist Association, National Scrip Collectors Association and Numismatic Literary Guild.
In addition to teaching ANA Summer Seminar students about U.S. tokens and Civil War-era numismatics for 17 years, Schenkman has presented many talks at the Association’s conventions. He has prepared competitive exhibits at state, regional and national shows, taking home a number of awards. He received the ANA Glenn Smedley Memorial Award in 2003 and Medal of Merit in 2007.
JOHN NEBEL AWARDED ANA'S MEDAL OF MERIT
There's another E-Sylum connection to an ANA awardee - John Nebel. Along with Mark and Myrna Lighterman, John has been awarded a Medal of Merit by the American Numismatic Association. Most readers may not realize it, but John is a big reason behind the success of The E-Sylum - he provides free hosting for the NBS web site and E-Sylum archives, and developed and maintains the computer programs that create the archive web pages, tables of contents, and RSS feeds. He was also instrumental in setting up and maintaining the NBS Wiki, enabling the great trove of numismatic bibliographic information that Tom Wetter is assembling for us. Thanks, and Congratulations! Here's an excerpt from the ANA press release. -Editor
ANA life member John Nebel is a computer consultant who has volunteered his time and expertise to meet the Association’s technology needs. A Colorado resident, Nebel has taught numismatic photography at the ANA Summer Seminar, where he supports scholarship programs by donating high-value ancient coins to the Young Numismatist Benefit Auction. His numismatic photographs grace the ANA’s Colorado Springs headquarters as well as the pages of The Numismatist, and he freely shares images of ancient Greek and Roman coinage on his website, www.ancientmoney.org .
Nebel’s firm, Computer Systems Design Company, hosts the websites of more than 50 ANA-member clubs at no charge. Thanks to CSDC, the ANA’s Bebee Collection of U.S. Paper Money also has been digitized and made accessible online for all. Nebel has been recognized with a Presidential Award (2009) and the Glenn Smedley Memorial Award (2010).
AN INTERVIEW WITH ROBERT HOGE
CoinUpdate published an interview with ANS Curator and CCAC member Robert Hoge. Here's an excerpt. -Editor
Robert Hoge was sworn into the Citizens Coinage Advisory Committee (CCAC) on April 26th, 2012. He was appointed as the member specially qualified to serve by virtue of his education, training or experience in numismatic curation. Mr. Hoge is curator of North American Coins and Currency for the American Numismatic Society (ANS), and an award-winning columnist of ANS Magazine. In addition, he is president of the New York Numismatic Club. From 1981 to 2001, he served as curator for the ANA's Money Museum in Colorado Springs and manager of its Authentication Bureau. Mr. Hoge holds a Bachelor of Arts degree in anthropology and history from the University of Colorado at Boulder, and a teaching certification in social sciences.
Mr. Hoge agreed to answer some questions regarding his entry into numismatics, and his thoughts on the U.S. Mint and the CCAC.
What is your earliest coin collecting memory?
At ten years old, I found a coin (it actually turned out to be a token) in the dirt floor of a garage/shed at my family home. This piqued my imagination, and I wanted to identify and learn something about it. The thing appeared to be a $20 gold piece, but was clearly made of brass. It was very badly worn and pitted, but eventually I was able to figure out that it was a circa 1850s spielmark. My parents started supporting my new interest by encouraging me and giving me actual old coins.
How did you start collecting coins?
With some coins initially given to me by family members and friends, I began reading about coin collecting and studying the relationships of numismatics to history and archaeology. I saved all the older or more unusual ones I could find, and was thrilled when other school children showed me different coins that they had found or gotten from their parents. Scouting introduced me to the idea of collecting coins by series. My father had collected U.S. coins years earlier, and started giving me his partially-filled little blue Whitman albums. My mother made note of interesting coins that I happened to have mentioned, and began to hunt for dealers from whom she could get some for me as little gifts. I started seeking magazine advertisements listing coins for sale and upcoming coin shows, started acquiring a few inexpensive coins from dealers, and bothered my parents to help with this. I had a broad interest in the past, and a good memory; consequently, my numismatic proclivity burgeoned.
What coins do you collect?
I do not actively collect anything today, although in the past my numismatic interests have varied fairly widely, to the extent I could afford to make occasional purchases. From my initial fondness for Early American coins, I moved toward ancient and oriental issues as I studied languages and cultures, and I have collected many series -- as long as they contained diverting items that were relatively inexpensive. I never managed to complete any sets of United States coins of any kind, unfortunately, but I suppose I should confess that I do possess examples of coinage of most of the Roman emperors and British monarchs, for example – areas in which I have devoted more focused study.
To read the complete article, see: Interview with Robert Hoge, CCAC Member (news.coinupdate.com/interview-with-robert-hoge-ccac-member-1511/)
ANS RAYMOND H. WILLIAMSON CORRESPONDENCE ARCHIVE
I came across this item online this week - it's the entry for Ray Williamson in the American Numismatic Society archive collection. -Editor
Raymond H. Williamson correspondence, 1949-1996 0.5 cubic feet (1 box)
Williamson had an early interest in radio, operating an amateur station from 1921 to 1926. He managed a naval radio telegraph transmitter in the Panama Canal Zone in 1936 and 1939 and was chairman of the FM Broadcast Engineering Committee that set industry standards from 1942 to 1953. He began collecting coins in 1917 and published articles in The Numismatist, The Colonial Newsletter, Penny-Wise, The Virginia Numismatist, and other publications. Williamson became an associate member of the American Numismatic Society in 1949, a fellow in 1957, and chaired the Society’s U.S. coins committee in the 1950s. He was a member of the American Numismatic Association, Virginia Numismatic Association, and was charter member number 54 of the Early American Copper Society. He served on the U.S. Assay Commission in 1968.
Williamson’s early correspondence (1949-1953) with the young Breen document a time when Breen was conducting research for coin dealer Wayte Raymond at the National Archives and the U.S. Mint and working at the Smithsonian Institution with Stuart Mosher, editor of The Numismatist. Also during that period, Breen worked briefly at the coin auction firm Stack’s, was a student at Johns Hopkins University, and began publishing on early American coinage. The letters reveal a friendship built around shared numismatic research interests.
To read the complete archive entry, see: Raymond H. Williamson correspondence, 1949-1996 0.5 cubic feet (1 box) (numismatics.org/Archives/Bio-williamson)
TIME CAPSULE: A 1994 USENET POST ON THE 1783 NOVA CONSTELLATIO PATTERNS
Google hosts a complete archive of the classic newsgroup forum from the days before browsers and blogs. So here's a blast from the past: A post I made to the Internet USENET group rec.collecting in July 21, 1994, just prior to that year's ANA convention. Here it is: -Editor
This week's Numismatic News announced that John Ford's
The coins were struck in April 1783 for Robert Morris,
The following is the story of Ford's acquisition of the set,
Ford bought the copper "five" in 1977. It was found in a Paris collection
"How much should I pay for it" he asked. "Just buy it," Ford said,
Before long John Ford got a call himself from the dealer, and later bought the
After holding the set for 15 years, Ford is apparently putting it up
To read the complete article, see: CLM: 1783 Nova Constellatio set for sale (/groups.google.com/forum/?fromgroups#!topic/rec.collecting/TkJyjIKj124)
HUGH SCONYERS AND THE 1982 RARE COIN MARKET
Here's another Time Capsule: Doug Winter writes in his latest blog about the horrible 1982 rare coin market and his encounter with big buyer Hugh Sconyers. -Editor
What a lot of people forget about the coin market in 1982 is that it was dismal. After the amazing precious metals price run-ups in 1979 and 1980, the market crashed in 1981 and by 1982, you literally couldn’t give coins away. More on that in a second…
Steve Ivy Rare Coins (which was to soon merge with Jim Halperin to form Heritage Rare Coins) was a great example of just how badly the coin market had been devastated. In 1979-1980, I believe that there were close to 200 people working at the firm. After the market tanked in 1981, most of the staff was let go. When I was hired, I think there were something like a dozen people on the staff. Amazing as it seems today, this small group of employees was tasked with the responsibility of putting together an ANA sale, selling the coins and collecting the money; not to mention the normal buying and selling associated with the show.
As I mentioned above, the coin market in 1982 was appallingly bad. There were tons and tons of great coins around and, compared to the heady days of 1979 and 1980, prices were cheap; sometimes as low as thirty or forty cents on the dollar. The problem was that no one had any money or any confidence in the market.
But, there was, it turned out, one person who was buying coins. His name was Hugh Sconyers.
Hugh wasn’t a real numismatist; he was involved in the investment world and he was known as being one of the smartest people to ever walk a bourse floor. He represented a group of investors who thought coins, in 1982, were cheap and he set out to buy millions of dollars of choice and rare United States pieces. His buying would peak at the Eliasberg sale in October 1982 where he spent millions of dollars on amazing coins.
I never really knew Hugh that well; just mostly by sight and by reputation. I was told his checks were good (no simple feat in 1982…), he was at the show solely to buy coins and this made him The Most Wanted Man at Boston ANA. There was a bit of a problem though. Hugh was a “personality buyer.” What I mean by this is that Hugh bought coins mostly from people he knew and trusted. This meant that a number of dealers who would have given their first born child to have an hour with Hugh at the table buying their coins would never have the opportunity.
As soon as Steve Ivy found out about Hurricane Hugh, he called me over and gave me a new job at the show. The conversation, which lasted about thirty seconds, went like this:
Steve: I want you to stop whatever you are doing and follow Hugh Sconyers around the show and take notes about what he’s buying. I want to know who he buys from, what he’s buying, and how much he’s paying. What are you waiting for? Go!
Me: Uh, OK.
So my first day at my first ANA show as a professional coin dealer went like this: I had a note pad and a pen and I followed Hugh from a distance. Let’s say he stopped at Joe Flynn’s table. I figured my job was to get just close enough that I could spy on Hugh and give a detailed report to Steve. So as Hugh was flipping through Flynn’s double row boxes, I was at the next table pretending to look at coins out in the nearby case(s). Or something like that…
Here's my memory of the 1982 coin market. At that Boston show I ran into a man with a briefcase filled with proof U.S. type coins, all bargain priced in the $100-300 range. I had had the good fortune of buying a nice proof three-cent nickel for $200 about 1978, and I was able to sell it for about $2,000 before the market tanked. It was dumb luck, since I wanted the cash before heading to college. I looked at that case thinking I should buy the whole thing, but like everyone else at the time I had little spare cash. I'm sure Hugh Sconyers and his investors did well. -Editor
To read the complete article, see: ANA (Mis) Adventures: 1982 (www.raregoldcoins.com/market-blog/ana-mis-adventures-1982)
THE BOOK BAZARRE
THE LONDON 2012 OLYMPIC MEDALS
David Klinger writes:
Here is some information about the current Olympic medals which I found interesting.
The precious ore for the medals has been supplied by London 2012 sponsor Rio Tinto and was mined at Kennecott Utah Copper Mine near Salt Lake City in America, as well as from the Oyu Tolgoi project in Mongolia. For the small amount of non-precious elements that make up the bronze medals, the zinc was sourced from a mine in Australia as well as from recycled stock, while the tin originates from a mine in Cornwall.
Thanks! Below is the rest of the information from the web page David found. -Editor
Designed especially for each Games, the medals are what every athlete strives to win.
The medals at the London 2012 Olympic Games will be awarded during a total of 302 Victory Ceremonies, taking places at venues across the UK.
The medals have been designed by David Watkins, an established artist in the field of decorative art, and are in production at the Royal Mint headquarters in Llantrisant, South Wales.
The story behind the medal
The design for the reverse features five symbolic elements:
How the designs were chosen
An independent panel of Sir John Sorrel (chair), Sir Mark Jones, Catherine Johnson, Ade Adepitan (deputy chair), Iwona Blazwick OBE, Niccy Hallifax and Martin Green was set up to look at the designs submitted by over 100 artists. The LOCOG Athletes’ Committee, chaired by Jonathan Edwards, and the British Olympic Association (BOA) were also involved throughout the process.
The medals can be seen at the British Museum throughout the Games.
To read the complete article, see: www.london2012.com/medals/about/
BELGIUM'S BELGA CURRENCY
With all of the recent headlines surrounding the Euro and the possibility of Greece and other countries leaving the Euro zone, this article from CoinsWeekly is timely. It discusses the Belga, a currency created by Belgium when it left behind the Belgian Franc in a time of monetary trouble. Here's an excerpt from the article by Franky Leeuwerck. Be sure to read the complete version online. -Editor
About a decade ago I spotted a Belgian share of the Walburg textile company from the city of St-Niklaas.
At first sight it looked like a rather plain certificate. But I was puzzled because it was not mentioning the familiar Belgian Franc as its currency denomination but Belgas. Thundering typhoons, what were Belgas?
A strong Belgian Franc for King Leopold II
Reichsmarks induce Belgium inflation
The following years saw a continuous fall of the value of the Franc in comparison to the Pound Sterling and the US Dollar, causing further flight of Belgian capital. Eventually, the government Poullet-Vandervelde was forced to resign. Strong measures were needed to stabilize the Belgian currency and to put the evolution of the Belgian national debt back on the right track.
Belgium leaves the Latin Monetary Union and introduces the Belga
Belga coexists with Belgian Franc
1927 saw appearing the first notes mentioning both currencies and 3 year laters ‘Belga-Franc’ coins appeared on the market. Nevertheless, the plan was a success and did stabilize the Belgian currency.
The Belga was not popular when it was used and it was soon forgotten after it disappeared from the market. In the past decades the Belga was seldom mentioned in history lessons at schools, so nowadays few people know about its past existence. And that explains the mystery of the Belga, people simply forgot about the Belga except for collectors of coins and notes.
To read the complete article, see: Twenty years of Belgas (www.coinsweekly.com/en/Twenty-years-of-Belgas/8?&id=210&type=a)
FEATURED WEB PAGE: UNITED STATES MINT POSTCARDSThis week's Featured Web Page, suggested by David Lange, has images of Stereoviews, Post Cards etc. illustrating scenes of and at the various United States Mint buildings.
"Write Karl Moulton and get him to publish his collection of these cards" Alan Meghrig