Carol Bastable is the President and webmaster of the Love Token Society and also writes for the society's newsletter, Love
letter. She writes:
I recently researched a Victorian period book on engraving and discovered some information. It confirmed some of my previous research
on love token initials which had been based on observations over time and population studies.
Carol kindly forwarded a copy of the August 2015 Love Letter, which includes her article, Late Date Love Token Design and
Monograms. Thanks! Here's an excerpt. -Editor
It has been mentioned previously in the Love Letter that love tokens with initials underwent design changes in their later years of
production. The information was arrived at by studying thousands of love tokens over time and finding a correlation between the date on the coin and
the style of design that was engraved. Now, conclusive printed proof on the matter has been found.
I recently saw an antique engraving book on eBay and thought how interesting it would be to read and research its history, so I
purchased it. The book “Modern Letter Engraving” was written by Fred Holmes Rees. and published in 1898.
A number of the early chapters take the reader through engraving the same script font, letter by letter, in both upper and lower case,
and address spacing between letters. There was one page on flourish design which followed the chapters on individual letter engraving.
“Flourishes” are the squiggle lines that are used to decorate outside of the letters and give a decorative effect to the background
In chapter 15 the author mentions that only a few years prior (keep in mind the 1898 publication date), engravers placed articles to be
engraved on sand bags to hold them or even held an item in one hand and the engraving tools in the other hand. He then informs the reader of new
devices including the Monarch engraving block, which resembles a modern engraving ball used today. The latter half of the book discusses engraving
Roman, Old English, Gothic, and block letters. It is mentioned that Old English is the second favorite style, with script being number one in
popularity. Old English was said to be plain enough to be readable yet at the same time very ornamental.
There are several pictures of highly ornate ciphers and monograms shown in the last five chapters of the book. Some are akin to love
token design and some are possibly even more ornate than what is seen on love tokens. Chapter 29 covers block letter monograms. These are
what love token collectors have been calling double and triple overlapping letters. Perhaps we should adjust our term and embrace the
correct one as written in the book, “block monograms”. That being said, much of what we have been calling monograms (made using overlapping
script letters) are also referred to a little differently with the words “cipher” and “script monograms”.
What is of interest in the block letter monogram chapter is what the author says about them: “Fancy block monograms are not as commonly
used now as they were a few years ago, but we should know how to engrave them.” Remember the book was printed in 1898, and it confirms that this
style of monogram was on the way out and being replaced by script monograms. The book includes the picture of a circular grid that was used in the
making of block monograms.
All in all, the book was interesting and it really gives a love token collector an appreciation for all the work that goes into
designing and engraving a monogram. I was hoping for even more clues to love tokens and found myself quickly skimming though the sections
on how to engrave individual letters A-Z. The idea of searching for and reading old engraving books is an interesting prospect. Next time
maybe a book published in the late 1870’s or early 1880’s, provided one exists, would be even more fruitful.
At my request Carol provided some examples of the different Love Token lettering styles. Thanks! -Editor
Script Style Cipher Love Token Designs on a Peace Dollar and Quarter Eagle
Old English Love Tokens Designs on a Shield Nickel and Dimes (Gold Overlay)
Block Letter Love Token Designs on a Bust Half and Liberty Nickel
A cipher does not overlap as fully as a monogram. The block letters are stacked one on top of another and in the cipher, one can place
the order as two letters appear just left and right of the center one. Victorian block letters are far more ornate than what we think of
today as block letters.
It's important for the hobby to get its terminology correct, and aligning our descriptions with those used by the makers of Love
Tokens is a useful step. But manufacturers and collectors are different breeds of animals, and a perfect alignment may not be possible.
But connecting with the makers through these contemporary writings is an ideal first step. Kudos to Carol for finding this information
and bringing it to the attention of the numismatic community. Do any of our readers know of other books on the topic that may shed
additional light on the issue? -Editor
To read the book on Google Books, see:
Modern letter engraving in theory and
For more information on the Love Token Society, see:
Wayne Homren, Editor
The Numismatic Bibliomania Society is a non-profit organization
promoting numismatic literature. See our web site at coinbooks.org.
To submit items for publication in The E-Sylum, write to the Editor
at this address: firstname.lastname@example.org
To subscribe go to: https://my.binhost.com/lists/listinfo/esylum
Copyright © 1998 - 2020 The Numismatic Bibliomania Society (NBS)
All Rights Reserved.
NBS Home Page
Contact the NBS webmaster