The Numismatic Bibliomania Society



The E-Sylum: Volume 22, Number 10, March 10, 2019, Article 21


Last Friday (March 1, 2019) I left work early and headed north toward Baltimore for the Whitman Baltimore Coin Expo. I arrived on the bourse floor about 3pm and found len Augsburger at the Seated Fest II table. We had plans to meet for dinner later. I had invited David Sundman of Littleton Coin and Len invited young numismatist Garrett Ziss and his parents. I had some time to kill and walked around the show visiting with friends old and new.

Charles Davis
First I visited numismatic literature dealer Charlie Davis. Already there was NBS Past President Michael J. Sullivan. We talked about his great consignment of paper money numismatic literature in that evening's Stack's Bowers sale. See the article in last week's issue for more information.

Later Charlie showed me a photo from the 1981 New Orleans ANA convention which included Jim King and Ann King, Arthur Fitts, Dick Margolis, and Charlie Wallace. Thanks!

This photo was removed per a family request

Craig Sholley
While hanging out at Charlie's table Craig Sholley and his wife Bonnie came by. Craig showed me an electrotype of the Jefferson Head cent made from the piece in the American Numismatic Society collection. Beautiful piece.

Electrotype S80 Jefferson Head cent obverse Electrotype S80 Jefferson Head cent reverse

Craig also had with him the only known striking from the Newman-107 obverse Fugio die, a double-struck die trial over a 1798 DB cent.

Fugio Cent Newman 107 die trial obverse Fugio Cent Newman 107 die trial reverse

Craig adds:

The S80 electro would be perhaps the nicest known if some idiot hadn't "spooned" the edge in a futile attempt to hide the seam.

The Newman 107 die trial had previously been misidentified as both Newman 105 and 106. I identified it a few weeks ago based on the positions of the two lower cinquefoils, which are unique to 107.

As chance would have it, another nice electrotype walked up in the hand of Alan Weinberg. It was a holed Washington skull & crossbones funeral medal.

Northeast Numismatics
Tom Caldwell and Chris Clements of Northeast Numismatics had some time to spare and we talked for a good while. They didn't have their newly acquired Don Lutes discovery specimen of the 1943 copper cent with them, but they will display it at at the upcoming Bay State show in Marlboro, Massachusetts.

Tom Caldwell Chris Clements Northeast Numismatics 2019-03 Whitman Coin Expo
Tom Caldwell and Chris Clements

I looked through their stock and asked about the "Ghost" Oak Tree Shilling. They explained that the variety is so named because of the shallow relief and thin, spindly nature of the tree. Great piece. Here's my photo of it in their case, followed by shots from their web site.

Ghost Oak Tree Northeast Numismatics 2019-03 Whitman Coin Expo
The Ghost Oak Tree Shilling

Ghost Oak Tree shilling obverse Ghost Oak Tree shilling reverse

To view the coin on the Northeast web site, see:

Stephen Album Rare Coins

Stephen Album table 2019-03 Whitman Coin Expo

I also stopped by the table of Stephen Album Rare Coins and spoke to Mike Barry. I looked at a number of pieces but what most caught my eye was this Balloon School medal.

Baloon School medal obverse Baloon School medal reverse
The Balloon School Medal

John Kraljevich
Dennis Addison Emancipation Proclamation dog tag reverse I probably spent more time at the table of John Kraljevich than anywhere else. We mostly discussed the Newman Numismatic Portal (and how to make finding information easier) and the emancipation dog tags illustrated in the last E-Sylum. These are fascinating pieces.

Jon Sullivan Error Coins
In recent issues I've illustrated some great error coins from the stock of dealer Jon Sullivan of John's Island, SC. I had never met him so I introduced myself at his table and we had a nice conversation.

Jon Sullivan 2019=03 Whitman Coin Expo

While discussing The E-Sylum Jon suggested a neat coin he recently acquired. It appears to be a U.S. Large cent struck over what could be a Canadian coin or token. He didn't have the piece with him but provided these images for publication. What do people think of this?

1851 large cent error obverse 1851 large cent error reverse

1851 large cent error edge

Jon adds:

The coin is an 1851 large cent and is a double-struck broadstrike, with a partial collar strike on the edge and a uniface 2nd strike on the reverse. It has a partial collar strike on the edge, and is slightly "cupped up" on one side of the coin (similar to a die cap.) The coin is also struck over a planchet that weighs 8.04 grams (a normal large cent weighs significantly more at 10.89 grams.) The planchet is copper.

There is a gouge in the obverse, and a few scratches (not an error.)

In a small amount of searching around, I discovered that a 1850's Canadian half-penny weighs about 7.9 grams (within tolerance for this coin) and also has a diameter of 27.6mm (which is 0.1% larger than a large cent (which is 27.5mm), but that also might account for the coin's partial collar…since it might've had a little trouble falling all the way into the large cent collar.)

The 1870-S Half Dime
At the Seated Fest II tables I asked to look at the 1870-S Half Dime. As it happened, the owner of the piece was there and he got it out of the case for me. I was curious to get an in-person look at the mintmark, which looked like a blob in the publicity images I'd seen.

H10C-1870-S-obv H10C-1870-S-rev

H10C-1870-S-rev Yep. It's a blob. The owner agreed.

Dinner With Garrett Ziss
I later mentioned the piece to Garrett Ziss. He agreed as well, and may have invented a new word - "Yes, it's really blobular."

Around 6 I met up with my dinner party - Len, David, Garrett and his parents. Len had made a reservation at Sullivan's. We walked over in the rain but were quickly seated at a nice table. Dave ordered some wine. The meals were excellent and exceeded only by the fine conversation.

Topics included German beer steins, the Wilmington Coin Club, Jules and Iona Reiver, the Bust Nut Half Club, travel, Dave's Massachusetts silver collection, the ANA Summer Seminar, 1794 dollars (real and fake), the Invasion of Louisville, John Ford, the Nova Constellatio pattern set, the American Journal of Numismatics and much more. It was a very enjoyable evening of numismatic fellowship.

Dave walked with me back to my car (it was still raining!) and I gave him a ride over to his hotel, the Marriott. I had an hour's drive to get home but I didn't mind at all. What a great night.

NEXT UP: On Tuesday I have the regular dinner meeting of Nummis Nova, my Northern Virginia numismatic social group. If any readers are in town and would like to join us, let me know.

And later this month I'll be in Pittsburgh for the ANA's National Money Show. I'm attending the Welcome Banquet Wednesday night. If you'll be there and would like to share my table, let me know. It should be a fun night in a great venue.

To read the earlier E-Sylum articles, see:

HLRC E-Sylum ad06 Buying

Wayne Homren, Editor

NBS ( Web

The Numismatic Bibliomania Society is a non-profit organization promoting numismatic literature. See our web site at

To submit items for publication in The E-Sylum, write to the Editor at this address:

To subscribe go to:



Copyright © 1998 - 2012 The Numismatic Bibliomania Society (NBS)
All Rights Reserved.

NBS Home Page
Contact the NBS webmaster