Mike Costanzo submitted this article about another present-day connection to Doris Baum, who modeled for the Standing Liberty Quarter.
-Editor
Herman MacNeil's Miss Liberty and Karl Bitter's Pomona
In Sara Cedar Miller's 2003 book, Central Park, An American Masterpiece, Miller revealed a
numismatic tidbit regarding model Doris Discher Baum, who posed for Herman MacNeil's
Standing Liberty quarter. While the controversy surrounding the identity of MacNeil's model is
well known, Baum apparently kept her involvement with another statue a secret as well.
In 1916, the Pulitzer Fountain was dedicated at Fifth Avenue and 59th Street, along the
outskirts of Central Park. The fountain featured a statue of Pomona, the Roman goddess of
abundance. While working on the figure, sculptor Karl Bitter was killed in a car accident, and an
assistant completed the piece. For whatever reason, Baum chose to keep her identity a secret and
later revealed it along with her revelation that she also posed for a piece of American coinage.
Miller's text reads:
"For years people could only guess at the identity of the model for Pomona, but the secret was
revealed in 1966 on the once-popular television show I've Got a Secret. Eighty-four-year-old
Doris Discher Baum claimed that not only had she posed for the Pomona, but she was also the
model for the Miss Liberty quarter first minted in 1916. It may be true, but perhaps in a flight of
fancy she identified with Alice Butler from Windsor, Vermont, who was one of the models for
Saint-Gaudens Victory across the street as well as the classically profiled Liberty for his ten- and
twenty-dollar gold pieces.
"Baum's revelation concerning the Pomona statue was naturally overshadowed by the publicity
surrounding the quarter and soon forgotten. It is interesting to note her proximity to Saint
Gauden's Sherman Monument and model Alice Butler, who was used for his twenty-dollar gold
piece, a fact not lost on Miller. It is also ironic that the Pomona statue and Standing Liberty
quarter both debuted in 1916.
As an interesting footnote, Miller claimed that millionaire Cornelius Vanderbilt III sold his
mansion because "he took offense to his rear view of Pomona."
Author Jim Haas discussed this connection in an earlier article.
Follow the link below for more. Here's a video of that segment of the show.
I'm old enough to remember watching I've Got a Secret on television, but I don't recall this episode.
-Editor