SUTLERS’ SCRIP: SHOPPING WITH THE SOLDIER

Sutlers–private operators of the Army’s version of a travelling general store–operated in their own realm separate from the military supply chain. Catering to the soldier, they aimed to add some comforts to camp life – at a price. The sutler offered non-regulation items the quartermaster could not, or would not, provide. These products included razors, tobacco, watches, sewing kits, stamps, ink, boot polish, brushes, newspapers, envelopes, books, canned food and more. When available, they offered fresh fish, oysters, fruit, vegetables, and dairy. Pies were very popular, even if their content was sometimes suspect. Most desirable was coffee, though if regimental leadership had a lax enough policy about it, alcohol could be had as well.

While sutlers had a reputation for price-gouging, prices reflected the risk of bringing the goods (and themselves) to the front lines in addition to scarcity. Complain as they might, a soldier knew if they refused to pay the inflated costs, someone else would.

 
Sutler’s Row, Chattanooga, Tennessee. Photo by Matthew Brady

Army regulations allowed sutlers to be appointed at the rate of one for every regiment, corps, or separate detachment by the commanding officer. Sutlery expanded exponentially along with the growing armies. State militias allowed commanders considerable leeway in appointing (or at least permitting) merchants to sell goods to the men. Mustered in with their own uniforms and weapons, sundry goods were never a priority or logistical reality.

To say there was friction between sutlers and the military is an understatement. The sutler, who was a civilian and not an officer, held no authority over soldiers. They bristled at regulations and the possibility of military punishment. Some officers viewed sutlers as another opportunity to leak military secrets or movements, degrade combat readiness, and spread rumors. Still, the demand for convenient goods, a lack of alternatives, and overtaxed quartermasters meant no real competition for the sutler. While often painted as parasitic, the incentive to maintain lucrative appointments and keep their captive market satisfied probably self-regulated sutlery more than the army would admit. Their individual legacies deserve better than being known simply as con artists.

The sutler obtained goods from a variety of contractors and local markets, but if he sold substandard product, it was the sutler and not the manufacturer who was the target of soldiers’ ire and retaliation. Meanwhile, the officers overseeing sutlery operations could be equally unscrupulous, manipulative, or even complicit in price-fixing. The sutler compensated by adjusting prices due to spoilage, loss, or theft, an endless cycle of everyone seeking advantage where they could.

The navy didn’t fare much better. While there was better access to goods in port, long stretches of blockade time or riverine warfare deep in enemy territory along the Mississippi, Cumberland, and Tennessee rivers did not allow for frequent resupply. Ships could be visited by “bumboats,” or merchants that might row up to a ship or even be allowed on board to offer their wares. Various sutler ships also operated on the rivers as a more expedient means of transport. But this system was unreliable and suffered the same criticism about substandard quality and overcharges.

The most under-reported aspect of sutlery was that even the most infamous prison camps, including Andersonville and Elmira, were intermittently serviced by sutlers. As both sides adopted increasingly cruel and retaliatory punishment, Stanton ultimately prohibited trade with prisoners in December 1863. He later relented somewhat when it was clear the harsh winters exacerbated the need for basic clothing and hygiene needs, and the federal government could benefit from the commercial venture. In the south, Confederate guards were willing to trade food for manufactured goods, jewelry, and greenbacks. The Federal prisoners used Confederate dollars to purchase whatever was available from the sutler.

 
Sutlers’ Stores, City Point, Virginia (now Hopewell), near Petersburg

To read the complete article, see:
Robbers Road and Sutlers’ Scrip: Shopping with the Soldier (https://emergingcivilwar.com/2026/02/04/robbers-road-and-sutlers-scrip-shopping-with-the-soldier/)

	NBS (coinbooks.org) Web