BOOK REVIEWS: U.S. PROOF COINS VOL III: SILVER

The previously published volumes of John Dannreuther's ongoing series United States Proof Coins have already established it as a landmark reference that will remain the gold standard on this topic for a generation or more. The recently published volumes on silver coins only add to its importance. While the meticulous listings of individual proof issues are what will receive the most attention (and will be consulted again and again by readers), the author's introductory chapters are of importance to anyone with the slightest interest in the history of U.S. coinage. Dannreuther's commentary on master coins and proofs would make for a very good book of its own, and he draws upon a wide variety of resources in researching the subject. Like many, I can't wait to add the copper volumes to my bookshelves!

I recently received the long awaited Volume III United States Proof Coins written by John Dannreuther. This is his third book on the subject of silver proofs, previously Vol IV on gold proofs and Vol II on nickel proofs have been released. I suspect the final volume 1 on copper proofs is in the works and probably will be released in a year or two.

This silver proof Vol. III is so far the largest encompassing two books for a total of 1,253 pages. Part one covers silver 3 cent pieces through quarters and consists of pages 1-684 while Part two covers half dollars thru silver dollars and pages 685-1,253.

The earlier Volume in gold also consisted of two books encompassing 1,031 pages and the Volume on nickel proofs was a single book consisting of 373 pages bringing the grand total to date a massive 2,657 pages. This is definitely one of the largest works in my library.

To describe the contents of Vol III, it first begins with a dedication, acknowledgements, forward, and glossary. Next is a very detailed group of chapters entitled, "Introduction to Proof Coinage," "Why and Where Were Master Coins and Proofs Made" and finally "How were Master Coins and Proofs Made." The above sections consist of 106 pages, truly a book within a book. Following that begins the series of individual dated proofs beginning with three cent silvers thru silver dollars. Virtually every coins description consists of several pages each. Mintage or estimated mintage of each issue is listed plus known survivors and even die characteristics or varieties are listed. Also known significant survivors, grades and auction records are noted. Commentary about each date and in many cases enlarged photos of portions of the coins are shown.

Dates covered, depending on the denomination begin about 1817 and carry through the twenties and thirties long before accurate records were kept by he mint. The individual coins section continues through the early 20th century however modern proofs are not included in his books.

Also of importance is the addition of many branch mint proofs. This area of research has always been clouded with mystery and open to much speculation. Some branch mint proofs are well documented, while other are looked upon with skepticism and doubt. Many have been refuted and have general disagreement within numismatic experts. Some have been certified and graded as proof while others have attained the "Specimen" designation. Danreuther has given this subject great thought and attention but has not included most controversial coins which are not generally accepted to be true proofs.

In conclusion, virtually everything you need to know about proof coins has been included masterfully in Danreuther's book.

This book and his other volumes are printed on high gloss quality paper and contain beautiful full color high resolution images of every coin and details were needed. They are hardbound in black cloth with the 2-Book sets on silver and gold editions contained in similar slipcases. The pre-publication price is no longer available but it can be purchased directly from the author or elsewhere in the internet. List price is $375.