For our bibliophiles: inspired by the announcement of a remake, here's an article about the heart of Nora Ephron's script for the classic rom-com "You've Got Mail". Here's an excerpt - see the complete article online.
-Editor
In Ephron's telling, Kathleen and Joe can't stand each other because she owns a small business and he is the heir to a Barnes & Noble–like behemoth mega-chain. In the hands of a lesser artist, that premise could mean only one thing: David good, Goliath bad. But Ephron, one of the most ingeniously astute observers of American life and culture, knew better. The real tension, she realized, wasn't between rapacious corporate America and the small business owners struggling to survive its onslaught but between one fantastic retail operation, a cozy nook where everybody knows your name, and another, a big, brightly lit emporium with a terrific selection and decent coffee. When these two compete, we all win, because that right there is the truly revolutionary nature of capitalism: replacing a very good product with an even better one, making money by giving us better options, always innovating and always growing and inviting us all along for the ride.
Joe himself puts it best. In one of the film's funniest scenes, he's incensed when a TV reporter, eager to frame the story as underdog local business fighting the evil national chain, edits Joe's interview to make it seem like he's a corporate hack who cares only about the bottom line. "That's not all I said," he rants to a friend, played by Dave Chappelle. "I said we were great. I said you could sit and read for hours and no one will bother you. I said we have 150,000 titles. I showed them the New York section. I said we were a goddamn piazza! A place in the city where people can mingle and mix and be." And if you truly love books, and New York, and spending time with other people, it's a very hard proposition to beat.
You've Got Mail works, then, not because it's a story of opposites attracting each other but because it makes it clear that Kathleen and Joe aren't opposites at all. They each start the film enmeshed with a partner who, on paper, couldn't be more suitable—she with a blowhard liberal writer glued to his typewriter, he with a soulless and striving publishing exec—but slowly realize that there's much more to life than such corny caricatures of left-wing piety or right-wing greed. They find their way into each other's arms because both ultimately care a lot about the book-buying experience. Great Americans that they are, they understand that shopping is no mere material exercise in wasting time and spending money, but a form of self-expression, an affirmation, an exercise in building community and generating value. We can imagine them snuggling on the couch long after the movie's over, drinking tall decaf cappuccinos and imagining how to make browsing for books even more gratifying for their friends and neighbors.
That was 28 years ago. These days, the Barnes & Noble on the Upper West Side is itself the quaint small business, a lone retail holdout in a city mile riddled with either empty storefronts or odorous cannabis dispensaries. Still, it thrives because it turns out Joe was exactly right: Now that buying books involves clicking buttons and waiting for some underpaid, overtaxed delivery worker to drop off your volume of choice at your doorstep, people are pining for that piazza feel again, which is why the number of independent bookstores in the U.S. has grown by 70 percent since 2020, and why, in 2024 alone, Barnes & Noble opened 50 new locations stateside, with dozens more coming soon.
To read the complete article, see:
Bring Back the America of ‘You've Got Mail'
(https://www.thefp.com/p/bring-back-the-america-of-youve-got)
Wayne Homren, Editor
The Numismatic Bibliomania Society is a non-profit organization
promoting numismatic literature. See our web site at coinbooks.org.
To submit items for publication in The E-Sylum, write to the Editor
at this address: whomren@gmail.com
To subscribe go to: Subscribe
Copyright © 1998 - 2025 The Numismatic Bibliomania Society (NBS)
All Rights Reserved.
NBS Home Page
Contact the NBS webmaster
|