About UsThe Numismatic Bibliomania Society is a non-profit association devoted to the study and enjoyment of numismatic literature. For more information please see our web site at coinbooks.org SubscriptionsThose wishing to become new E-Sylum subscribers can go to the following web page
Subscribe
MembershipThere is a membership application available on the web site Membership Application To join, print the application and return it with your check to the address printed on the application. Print/Digital membership is $40 to addresses in the U.S., and $60 elsewhere. A digital-only membership is available for $25. For those without web access, write to: Jeff Dickerson, Treasurer AsylumFor Asylum mailing address changes and other membership questions, contact Jeff at this email address: treasurer@coinbooks.org SubmissionsTo submit items for publication in The E-Sylum, write to the Editor at this address: whomren@gmail.com BUY THE BOOK BEFORE THE COINSale CalendarWatch here for updates! |
Content presented in The E-Sylum is not necessarily researched or independently fact-checked, and views expressed do not necessarily represent those of the Numismatic Bibliomania Society.
New subscribers this week include:
Rob Pennell.
Welcome aboard!
Thank you for reading The E-Sylum. If you enjoy it, please send me the email addresses of friends you think may enjoy it as well and I'll send them a subscription. Contact me at whomren@gmail.com anytime regarding your subscription, or questions, comments or suggestions about our content.
We have a new advertiser this week: Smalls Auctions of Australia. Thank you for your support! When you're out at coin shows or shopping online and encounter one of our advertisers, please thank them for supporting our weekly effort - we wouldn't be able to deliver our publication at this scale and frequency without their assistance.
This week we open with four new books, an obituary, updates from the Newman Numismatic Portal, lots of notes from readers, and more.
Other topics this week include the coins of England, U.S. paper currency, the New Jersey Numismatic Society, numismatic warrior queens, survival ratios, a new Treasure Talk from Bob Evans, auction previews, fake and questionable coins, and the origin of PCGS.
To learn more about transitional Large Cents, Jan Lis, Normand Pepin, XRF coin composition analysis, Blackinton medals, the 1940 Leech Cup, flowlines, the evolution of the American Numismatic Association seal as a medal, Chilean silver on the SS Central America, the Humbert slug, conventions of the International Plate Printers and Die Stampers Union, the American Colonization Society, the 1848 CAL. Quarter Eagle, and the Beaver Coin Room, read on. Have a great week, everyone!
Wayne Homren
Editor, The E-Sylum
The 2027 editions of Coins of England & the United Kingdom are available for preorder from Sovereign Rarities. Here's the announcement. -Editor
Sovereign Rarities are proud to present the 2027 editions of the Coins of England and the United Kingdom, otherwise known as the Standard Catalogue of English Coins, the historic reference work for British coins.
Comprising Pre-decimal and Decimal issues, and with over 5,000 price revisions, these are not only the go-to guide for collectors and detectorists alike, but are a fascinating insight into British history.
A Special Offerings in our Online Bookstore email from Kolbe & Fanning Numismatic Booksellers alerted me to this recently-published book on transitional Large Cents. They're out of stock now, but interested readers can contact author Ken Laymon at k_laymon@yahoo.com. -Editor
THE KNEASS-GOBRECHT TRANSITIONAL HEAD LARGE CENTS: 1835–1839.
Laymon, Kenneth.
N.p. 2025. 4to, original brown linen, gilt. 45 leaves, printed on one side only; illustrated in color. New. Item #7989
An interesting recent publication focusing on the five years that witnessed the transition from the Coronet Head to the Braided Hair large cents.
Whitman has published a new edition of 100 Greatest United States Paper Currency. Here is the press release. -Editor
Whitman Brands is pleased to announce the release of 100 Greatest United
States Paper Currency, Second Edition, a fully revised and updated exploration of America's most
celebrated banknotes. Authored by numismatic experts Art Friedberg and Dustin Johnston, the
new edition revisits the landmark reference first published in 2005, offering collectors a fresh
perspective on the rarity, history, artistry, and enduring appeal of United States paper money.
More than two decades after the original edition, the book returns with a newly evaluated and re- ranked selection of 100 remarkable banknotes, reflecting significant advances in numismatic research, market activity, and collector interest. Featuring expanded historical commentary, updated rarity information, and stunning high-resolution color photography, the second edition celebrates the extraordinary currency that has helped tell America's story for 250 years.
From legendary rarities such as the 1890 "Grand Watermelon" Treasury Note and the 1863 $20 Gold Certificate to collector favorites including the colorful 1869 "Rainbow" Notes and beautifully engraved 1896 Educational Series, the volume explores the most fascinating achievements in American banknote design and production. High-denomination icons, including the $10,000 Federal Reserve Note, appear alongside historically significant issues that remain accessible to today's collectors.
Charles Riley submitted this notice of the passing of dealer Jan Lis. Thank you. -Editor
Jan Lis died on 2nd October 2026 aged 85. He was born in the turbulence of wartime Poland and came to England as a boy in 1947 - despite this arrival at an early age he always retained a hint of his homeland in his voice. In the early 1970s he became the proprietor of the Beaver Hotel in Earls Court, London, so called because it had been an Overseas Visitor Centre for Canadians, whose national symbolic animal is the beaver. Alongside this he dealt in European art and commemorative medals under the monika of the Beaver Coin Room, exhibiting at the main coin fairs in England and occasionally overseas.
The latest addition to the Newman Numismatic Portal is a group photo of the New Jersey Numismatic Society. Project Coordinator Len Augsburger provided the following report. -Editor
New Jersey Numismatic Society Group Photo
Courtesy of Jeff Burke and Greg Heim, Newman Portal added a group picture of the New Jersey Society membership in 1989. Numismatic bibliophiles will immediately recognize Charles Davis, front row center, who seems to have not aged a day in nearly 40 years! Jeff and Greg were able to name almost all the members, but a few in the back row remain unidentified. E-Sylum readers are invited to chime in.
The David Lisot Video Library on the Newman Numismatic Portal can be found at:
https://nnp.wustl.edu/library/multimediadetail/522852
We highlight one of his videos each week in The E-Sylum. Here's one from 2016 featuring Prue Fitts. -Editor
George Cuhaj submitted these thoughts on Normand Pepin, and several photos. Thank you. -Editor
Sad to learn that my long time collector friend Normand Pepin has died.
We became friends during the heyday of NYC coin shows in the mid-1970s thru 1993 going to different club meetings three times a month (Long Island Coin Club, Flushing Coin Club) before we switched to the New York Numismatic Club and Bronx Coin Club and working the shows setting the bourse cases up, dealer signs and then participating in the Young Numismatist events.
We shared some interesting experiences such as attending Archbishop Fulton J. Sheen's funeral in December 1979 together. We attended the marathon Museum of Broadcasting Monty Python event, viewing every show in order. In my cathedral usher days I got him to assist in the trenches at some big events. We attended the NYC sale at the 7th regiment armory of the S.S United States china, silver service, art, and even stateroom blankets. However I could never get him to visit Wisconsin, and after his father's death, he never returned to Montreal where he still kept a family apartment. It took him several years to even dispose of his father's car, and as he could not drive he would sit in it during NYC's alternate side street clean days so it would not get a ticket.
Traces of Gold?
Dick Hanscom writes:
"Might I suggest that the presence of gold in these CN coins could be due to trace gold in the copper that could not be removed, or perhaps was not worth removing? I seem to recall reading that the Siberian copper kopeks were at a different standard from the Russian coppers because they had traces of gold that could not be refined out."
Fairbanks Coin Club Medals
Dick Hanscom writes:
"When I was growing up in Massachusetts, a friend of the family collected New Hampshire town medals in silver. I thought that was pretty neat, and collected them in bronze (I could not afford silver). Many of these were made by Blackinton, as well as Robbins. I continued for a short time after coming to Fairbanks in 1974. I still have them.
"Upon arrival in Fairbanks, I joined the Fairbanks Coin Club. At that time, the FCC Pioneer Medals were made by Wendells of MN. I was very familiar with Blackinton products and convinced the FCC to switch to Blackinton for their 1975 Pioneer medals. Blackinton continued to make the FCC medals until we stopped with the 1981 issue.
"In 1980, two $25 gift tokens were made for the Tiki Cove (pewter) and Black Angus (bronze) restaurants, with a brass "gold" nugget on the common obverse."
More on the Continental Dollars
Saul Teichman writes:
I saw the nice article on Robert Rodriguez's book and work on the silver Continental Dollars.
I created photo libraries which are available on the Newman portal for the following ones which may be of interest to collectors.
1776 Continental Dollars in Brass (Newman 1-A, 1-B) (https://nnp.washu.edu/documents/detail/continental-
1776 Continental Dollars in Pewter (Newman 1-A, 1-B)
(https://nnp.washu.edu/documents/detail/continental-
dollars-in-pewter-newman-1-a-1-b/8060468)
1776 Continental Dollars in Silver (Newman 1-C, 3-D)
(https://nnp.washu.edu/documents/detail/continental-
dollars-in-silver-newman-1-c-3-d/8060476)
1776 Continental Dollars (Newman 4-D, 5-D)
(https://nnp.washu.edu/documents/detail/continental-
dollars-newman-4-d-5-d/8060470)
Thank you! -Editor
To read the earlier E-Sylum article, see:
NEW BOOK: THE CONTINENTAL DOLLAR
(https://www.coinbooks.org/v29/esylum_v29n45a04.html)
Other topics this week include Bechtler Gold, Renaissance Medals, and Flowlines. -Editor
Here's another entry from Dick Johnson's Encyclopedia of Coin and Medal Terminology. -Editor
Survival Ratio. An estimate of the number of specimens still in existence as a percentage of the original quantity struck. This is usually based on the number of specimens that come on the market, or a survey of collections (or negatively an analysis of collectors' want lists). It indicates rarity of the specimen.
Anyone making a survival ratio estimate must take into consideration how the original quantity was distributed. Here are two theoretical examples (in the extremes): (1) Entire production was sent to museums throughout the world and they placed the items in permanent collections – the survival ratio could be 90-95% (widely dispersed and saved under excellent preservation conditions). (2) If all distributed to public, as a parade medal say, the survival ratio could be as low as 1% (narrow distribution without good preservation standards).
E-Sylum Feature Writer and American Numismatic Biographies author Pete Smith submitted this follow-up on a recent 1792 Half Disme offering. -Editor
The November 8 issue of The E-Sylum mentioned the upcoming sale of a 1792 half disme by Stack's Bowers on November 17. Here are two stories that are not mentioned in the Auction catalog.
My description of the coin took a full page in 1792: Birth of a Nation's Coinage. I thought the sale history was particularly interesting. This is what I wrote:
Continuing our conversation about Nick Graver's enigmatic ANA pins, E-Sylum Feature Writer and American Numismatic Biographies author Pete Smith submitted this article on the evolution of the American Numismatic Association seal as a medal. Thank you! -Editor
ANA Vice President Joseph Hooper proposed a design for an Association Medal that was published in the April 1892 issue of The Numismatist. His description included:
"A volume of Ancient History underneath the Numisma Students lamp;
meaning that the Science takes first place as a truthful historical record,
and is above written history. The rays of light thrown out from the flame
signify the light thrown on ancient history by our science. The aid of
education is shown by the hand pouring, from an ancient vial, oil into
the lamp."
The first ANA Convention badge with the seal was issued in 1910 with
a New York Numismatic Club reverse. It was struck by Whitehead and
Hoag in chocolate brown and 38 mm. Design was by Jonathan M.
Swanson. The first 200 were serial numbered. The book cover has no
title.
Doug Ward submitted these notes on lapel pins in general, and a discovery relating to the ANA pin Nick Graver asked about. Thanks! -Editor
I did some digging into lapel pins. Seemingly, screw back pins were not commonly made until
the early 1900s. The earliest example I found seems to date to 1881 with another to 1892, so
it's conceivable Nick's pins date to the 1890s, although doubtful. Those early pins were made
by a company well known to numismatists, now and particularly in the early 1900s – Whitehead
& Hoag. Founded in 1881, they were early innovators in all-things pins. They were also the
premier maker of medals for early numismatics prior to 1959, including many for the ANA and
ANS. And they had significant ties to the US Mint at Philadelphia. They struck the Heath Medal,
the ANA's first, as well as numerous others. They were much better known to the early
numismatic community than any other pin makers would have been.
Whitehead & Hoag was determined to incorporate their logo onto most medals and pins, and would charge more if it was excluded. For screw back pins, their logo was consistently located on the back of the screw nut. Unfortunately, the nuts on the back of Nick Graver's pins were removed decades ago, before he acquired them. This is probably why they became artifacts rather than being sold or distributed and why they remained together as a group. The only inscription on the back of the pins is the word "STERLING." That inscription also appears on the edge of the Heath Medal, together with "WHITEHEAD – HOAG." Again, in my limited searching, sterling silver was not commonly used to make screw back lapel pins and I found none similarly labeled. Sterling silver was commonly used to make numismatic medals. Early pins were more commonly made of brass, gilt brass and 10 or 14 carat gold.
In January 2025, our good friend Bob Evans began publishing a series of blog articles on the Finest Known website detailing his experience as co-discoverer and curator of the treasures recovered from the wreck of the S.S. Central America. Subject of the book "Ship of Gold", many exhibits, countless interviews and articles, books and auction catalogs feature the legendary haul of gold coins, bars, nuggets, gold dust and more from the 1857 shipwreck. Here's another excerpt - see the complete article online. -Editor
I first became aware of the S.S. Central America and its treasure in 1983. Project founder Tommy Thompson shared with me the research he had begun, a file containing Xerox copies of microfilm of newspapers from 1857, much of it barely legible.
This week's 'Special Offerings in our Online Bookstore' email from Kolbe & Fanning Numismatic Booksellers also included this interesting counterfeit detector. With permission, we're republishing the description here. Thank you. Sorry - it's already been sold. -Editor
WILLIS & CO.'S BANK NOTE LIST, AND COUNTERFEIT DETECTOR.
Willis & Co.
(Boston): (Hotchkiss & Co. and T. Groom & Co.). Volume VIII, No. 9 (June 1851). 4to, original printed pictorial advertising brown paper covers, accompanied by an additional sheet on the same stock comprising 4 additional pages of advertising. 24 pages; engraving on the front cover and in the text depicting "the new Fifty Dollar Gold piece, stamped by the U.S. Assayer at San Francisco." Covers a trifle worn and discolored. Very good or better. Item #7992
Dillistin pages 112–113. A particularly interesting issue of this short-lived publication, issued from 1843 until 1854, when financial difficulties brought it to an end. The early illustration of the Humbert slug is notable, as is the text accompanying it:
Three lots in the Archives International Auctions sale 118 showcase souvenir albums from the 1916, 1918 and 1921 conventions of the International Plate Printers and Die Stampers Union. Great history and workmanship. Below are the lot descriptions with additional notes from the consignor. -Editor
Consignor's note:
The 1916 Ottawa Convention Volume (BABNCo)
The 1916 Ottawa volume represents a foundational piece of early 20th-century international labor and security-printing heritage. Issued by the British American Bank Note Company (BABNCo) for the Canadian convention, it features an extraordinary, primary-period intaglio title plate executed on ultra-thin, translucent India paper rather than standard card stock. Its historical weight is directly linked to the landmark February 1916 Parliament Hill fire in Ottawa, which destroyed Canada's Centre Block and reshaped wartime security protocols surrounding government and financial printing. Produced in severely restricted, wartime press runs for delegates, its contemporary proof impressions were pulled directly off the steel die during original production. Having escaped both the disbinding practice of mid-century dealers and the catastrophic losses of the 1916 era, this volume remains a rare, intact witness to early Canadian security printing.
Ottawa, Canada....., July 17th–22nd, 1916. This oblong, cord-tied souvenir album has 23 pages, including the front cover. The cover bears an intaglio lion's head within an ornate frame with the Royal Arms, and the script-engraved title page features a beaver vignette with the American Bank Note Co., Ottawa imprint. The highlight is a superb full-page intaglio advertising poster for the British American Bank Note Company, Ottawa, "Incorporated 1866." It is printed in sepia with elaborate lettering, a winged allegorical female holding a torch aloft, and a list of the firm's products, including bank notes, bonds, stock certificates, cheques, drafts, bills of exchange, and postage and revenue stamps, along with its Montreal office at 2 Place d'Armes Square. Other BABNCo intaglio plates include a mountain railway river gorge and "View Westward in Prince of Wales Sound, Hudson's Strait," after a Dr. R. Bell photo of 1884. Also included are Elbert Hubbard's "Loyalty" in engraved script, and photogravures of the Parliament Buildings (the Centre Block burned in February 1916), Quebec City and a habitant weaver at her loom. Cover worn with small tears, foxing and toning; interior AU.
Here are some additional selected lots from the November 17-18 sale by Archives International Auctions. -Editor
Canada. Victoria 25 Cents, 1883 H, 25C. Heaton Mint. Mintage of 960,000 pieces, a scarce date in better grades. Even dove-gray toning with light high-point wear only. PCGS graded AU 50. PCGS certification #51011824. Composition: .925 fine silver, 5.81 grams, 0.1728 troy oz ASW.
Heritage Auctions will be holding their Khanum Jan Family Trust Collection Ancient Coins Showcase Auction on November 16, 2026. Select items are discussed below. -Editor
SELEUCID KINGDOM. Antiochus I Soter (281-261 BC). AR tetradrachm (29mm, 17.16 gm, 5h). NGC Choice AU 5/5 - 3/5, brushed. Ecbatana. Diademed head of Antiochus I right, dotted border / BASI?EOS / ANT-IOXOY, Apollo seated left on omphalus, testing three arrows in right hand, left hand on grounded bow; ??O monogram in upper left field, complex monogram in circle above grazing horse in lower left field. SC 409.1a var. (secondary monogram placement).
From the Khanum Jan Collection
Davisson's is holding their E-Auction 54 on November 18. Here's an overview from Allan, Marnie, & Lief Davisson. -Editor
E-Auction 54 closes this coming Wednesday, November 18th! Lots begin closing at 10 a.m. U.S. Central Time. Now is a perfect time to browse and place any early bids, and be sure to come back and bid live on Wednesday!
Our sale closes with an attractive offering of World and U.S. coinage, including a choice example of America's first gold dollar. Read on for the final survey of our November sale.
Our Wednesday auction opens, as do all our sales, with gold coins – ancient, world, and U.S. – highlighted by an attractive handful of US gold pieces. Especially notable are choice examples of two rare 19th century historic gold rush private issues minted during regional gold rushes — U.S. Territorial or Pioneer gold, and California Pioneer fractional gold (minted around the 1848 California Gold Rush) — catalogued by Walter Breen.
Stack's Bowers will be holding their next Showcase Auction November 16-25, 2026.. Select items are discussed below. -Editor
Extremely Rare High-Relief Small Module Franklin One of Five Recorded by Margolis 1777 B. Franklin Américain Portrait Medallion. Fur Cap without Spectacles. By Jean-Baptiste Nini. Margolis-11, Baiardi-Sibille 94, Greenslet GM-5, Storelli-LXII, Villers-Unlisted. Terracotta. 121.0 mm, approximately 9.4 mm at the edge. 264.0 grams. Obverse with incuse signature and date, NINI / F 1777 on truncation, left of coat of arms. B FRANKLIN AMERICAIN around, separated by five stops, with raised plain border. Small pellet in border at 12 o'clock, corresponding to a small fleur de lys impressed in the reverse inward from 10 o'clock. Made with a suspension hole from the top edge through to the back, as typical.
Oblique edges finished in a fairly pronounced but thin bevel around the reverse rim. Handsome light orange-brown terracotta is uniform in tone across the entire face. Sharply defined with a uniformly smooth surface texture typical of Nini originals. A small obverse edge chip is noted just past 2 o'clock affecting only the outer border, while the reverse is free of any such impairment. Rare, and nicer than most seen of these earlier high-relief types.
Small-diameter medallions in higher relief like this are believed to predate the lower-relief designs that saw wider distribution. There are multiple variants, yet all are very rare and command significant premiums over the more widely distributed Margolis-17 type, in low relief. In Margolis' detailed study, he located only five of this variety, including this, discovered in a secondary find of his holdings (along with the M-17 in the sale), explaining why it was not included in the primary offering of his Nini medallions in our Spring 2024 sale. Others were noted at the Musee des Beaux-Arts, Blois, France; the Fogg Art Museum at Harvard University and in another private collection, the latter example curiously missing its reverse fleur de lys. A direct comparison with an example of Margolis-10, this same type but without the obverse pellet at 12 o'clock and fleur de lys, reveals that they were made with precisely the same mold. If this is true of all Margolis-10 and 11 medallions, then they are numbered in exactly the sequence of production - all bearing the pellet, an addition to the mold, were made after all those without it.
Provenance: From the Richard Margolis Collection. Earlier from our (Stack's) Americana Sale of January 2009, lot 5657.
Stack's Bowers will be holding their next Showcase Auction Rarities Night on November 17, 2026. Select items are discussed below. -Editor
Unique and Intriguing 1912 Pattern Quarter Dollar Electrotrial By James Earle Fraser, of Buffalo Nickel Fame Judd-C1912-3 1912 Pattern Quarter Dollar. Uniface Obverse Electrotrial. Design by James Earle Fraser. Judd-C1912-3, Pollock-5175. Rarity-8+. White Metal. Plain Edge. Genuine (PCGS). Liberty head left, similar in some respects to that by Charles E. Barber seen on the regular issue Liberty Head nickel of 1883 to 1913, but less refined. Thirteen stars encircle the periphery, and the date 1912 is below. Several adjustment marks or similar as-made features on seen on the blank reverse. Both sides with uniform pewter gray color, and essentially as made.
This obverse electrotrial is privately made, by James Earle Fraser, who is best known among today's collectors as designer of the Buffalo nickel, 1913 to 1938. As reported when we (as Bowers and Ruddy) offered this piece in our July 1981 sale:
No pattern coins made from this design. Researcher William S. Nawrocki claims to have found an obscure reference in the Fraser files, of this as the design for a silver dollar. No plasters of this design in the Lepczyk sale. It is believed unique, and this is the plate coin for the type in both the Judd (10th edition) and Pollock (1994) references on pattern and related coinage, pp. 319 and 442, respectively, and is also plated on the uspatterns.com website. An intriguing piece for the advanced collector of Fraser's extensive and much-admired work.
Provenance: From the Charles "Cheech" Litman Collection. Earlier ex James Earle and Laura Gardin Fraser estate; Fred Weinberg, Numismatics Ltd.; our (Bowers and Ruddy's) William R. Sieck Collection sale, July 1981, lot 2424; our (Bowers and Ruddy's) Michael Steig Collection sale, September 1982, lot 1813; our (Bowers and Ruddy's) Rare Coin Review, No. 44, 1982, p. 9; Dave Berg Rare Coin Investments, Ltd. The plate coin for the type in both the Judd (10th edition) and Pollock (1994) references on pattern and related coinage, pp. 319 and 442, respectively, and is also plated on the uspatterns.com website.
Smalls Auctions will be holding Sale 389 on November 22, 2026. Select items are discussed below. -Editor
Smalls Auctions Sale 389 includes three coins that were once part of the renowned Jerome Remick Collection, which was sold through Spink, London in November 2006. Remick was the co-author of the 'Guidebook and Catalogue of British Commonwealth Coins', the definitive guide for the series, which was based on the comprehensive collection he assembled across many decades. The three coins on offer are a testament to his critical eye, achieving the highest known grades in the NGC and PCGS population reports.
Isle of Man 1709 Penny, NGC XF45 BN (Equal Finest Known) Highest graded NGC XF45 BN & PCGS VF20BN (1) & 25 BN (1)
A British Museum study proposes that a counterfeiter may have melted down more common ancient coins to create a fake rarity. Here's an excerpt - see the complete article online. -Editor
Can someone wonder that even a small bronze coin can raise a big question. Is it really ancient, or was it made much later to look that way?
In 2017, a coin from the Pember collection was brought to the British Museum to be compared with known examples before a sale. The design looked familiar, but some details didn't sit right next to other examples. The check grew into an investigation of a group of coins linked to Ithaca, the Greek island tied to the hero Odysseus.
What came out of it was unusual. The coins suspected of being forgeries may have been made from metal melted down from genuine ancient objects.
Is it too rare to be real? Numismatic experts squared off in the English county of Norfolk over the authenticity of a unique gold Anglo-Saxon thrymsa submitted by a metal detectorist. Here's an excerpt - see the complete article online. -Editor
The object was found at an undisclosed location and reported the Norfolk coroner to adjudicate whether it be declared treasure.
But at a remarkable hearing, a disagreement saw one expert suggest it could be a potentially unique discovery while two others questioned if it was even genuine.
The unusual proceedings attracted a packed courtroom at Norfolk County Hall, where metal detectorist Ray Jenkins was joined by friends and family to hear the fate of his discovery.
Even staff at County Hall had filled the public gallery, drawn by a fascinating archaeological mystery which was about to expose a fundamental disagreement between experts.
On one side was Dr Adrian Marsden, a specialist in historic coins, who insisted the gold coin, known as a thrymsa, was genuine.
On the other were Dr John Naylor, National Finds Adviser for the Portable Antiquities Scheme at the Ashmolean Museum, University of Oxford, and Dr Wendy Scott, a curator at Norwich Castle Museum, who both challenged its authenticity.
An incident at Arlington National Cemetery on Veteran's Day led to a Joint Service Commendation Medal award. Here's a CNN article excerpt - see the complete article online. -Editor
Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth awarded the soldier who reprimanded him and members of his staff at the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier a Joint Service Commendation Medal on Thursday.
A Pentagon official confirmed that Hegseth welcomed the 3rd Infantry Regiment, known as The Old Guard, to the Pentagon "where he proudly awarded Specialist Iglesias the Joint Service Commendation Medal for the execution of his duties at the Tomb of the unknown Soldier on November 11, 2026."
Here are some additional items in the media this week that may be of interest. -Editor
Coin World published a short article on the recent launch ceremony for the Gettysburg Address Quarter. Here's an excerpt - see the complete article online. -Editor
Between 1,000 and 1,500 members of the public, collectors and invited guests joined the United States Mint at Gettysburg National Military Park Oct. 21 to celebrate the release of the Gettysburg Address quarter dollar, the fifth and final quarter dollar in the 2026 Semiquincentennial Circulating Coin Program.
ACNB, formerly known as Adams County National Bank in Gettysburg, served as the coin exchange sponsor, exchanging for like cash $30,000 in 40-coin rolls of 1776~2026-P Gettysburg Address quarter dollars.
Participating purchasers were at first permitted to exchange cash for a maximum 10 rolls per person, but that was later reduced to two rolls to allow all those standing in line to get some of the new coins.
Brandon Beach, Treasurer of the United States, and Paul Hollis, Director of the Mint, spoke at the event.
"More than 160 years after President Lincoln spoke at Gettysburg, his words continue to resonate," said United States Mint Director Paul Hollis. "This quarter carries his powerful message of liberty, sacrifice, and national purpose forward to a new generation."
"Gettysburg is a place where the meaning of Lincoln's words continues to resonate," said Gettysburg National Military Park Superintendent Stephanie Stephens. "This quarter provides a unique opportunity to carry the Gettysburg Address — and its enduring message of sacrifice, liberty, and a government of the people — into the hands of Americans across the country."
To read the complete article, see:
Crowd turns out at final quarter launch
(https://www.coinworld.com/news/us-coins/crowd-turns-out-at-final-quarter-launch)
To read the earlier E-Sylum article, see:
GETTYSBURG ADDRESS QUARTER LAUNCH CEREMONY
(https://www.coinbooks.org/v29/esylum_v29n42a26.html)
Other topics this week include Fake Military Commemorative Coins, and a medieval gold reliquary cross. -Editor
A CoinWeek article tells the story of the origin of the Professional Coin Grading Service (PCGS). Here's an excerpt - see the complete article online. -Editor
The story begins in 1985, when several prominent coin dealers regularly gathered after coin shows to work on an ambitious research project.
Their original goal involved producing a comprehensive reference book. They wanted to combine coin prices, rarity information, auction transactions, and grading research into a powerful numismatic resource.
However, the discussions increasingly focused on a problem that threatened the rare coin market.
For our bibliophiles: inspired by the announcement of a remake, here's an article about the heart of Nora Ephron's script for the classic rom-com "You've Got Mail". Here's an excerpt - see the complete article online. -Editor
In Ephron's telling, Kathleen and Joe can't stand each other because she owns a small business and he is the heir to a Barnes & Noble–like behemoth mega-chain. In the hands of a lesser artist, that premise could mean only one thing: David good, Goliath bad. But Ephron, one of the most ingeniously astute observers of American life and culture, knew better. The real tension, she realized, wasn't between rapacious corporate America and the small business owners struggling to survive its onslaught but between one fantastic retail operation, a cozy nook where everybody knows your name, and another, a big, brightly lit emporium with a terrific selection and decent coffee. When these two compete, we all win, because that right there is the truly revolutionary nature of capitalism: replacing a very good product with an even better one, making money by giving us better options, always innovating and always growing and inviting us all along for the ride.
My big numismatic event this week was visiting the Whitman Baltimore Expo on Thursday - I expect to have a Diary article in next week's issue.
Back in the day I had quite a collection of vinyl record albums (which are coming back into style now in a more niche market). I was reminded of that long-sold collection when I came across an online offering of Alice Cooper's 1973 "Billion Dollar Babies". What caught my eye was the inclusion of a Billion Dollar Babies banknote.
There's no end to the marketing applications of ersatz banknotes and I've never tried collecting these. But one generation's junk is another generation's treasure - today we have books cataloging 19th century advertising notes. Maybe this baby will end up in a slab up for auction all by itself.
Seen online: "I may be the only person in the world who doesn't much like Oreos. To me, they taste like potting soil discs with lard in between."
And here are some interesting non-numismatic articles I came across this week. The first one is a fun read about my favorite watering hole, the neighborhood bar I grew up near back in Pittsburgh. It's thriving today, and I recommend it to anyone visiting town.
What Makes The Bulldog Pub Much More Than Just a Neighborhood Watering Hole (https://www.pittsburghmagazine.com/what-makes-the-bulldog-pub-much-more-than-just-a-neighborhood-watering-hole/)
The 100-Year-Old Pittsburgh Bakery Whose Ovens Never Go Cold (https://opensince.substack.com/p/the-100-year-old-pittsburgh-bakery)
Reclaiming Mary Cassatt: putting overlooked American artist back at heart of impressionism (https://www.theguardian.com/artanddesign/2026/nov/15/reclaiming-mary-cassatt-putting-overlooked-american-artist-back-at-heart-of-impressionism)
'Depicts humanity at its most grotesque': Why the 300-year-old novel Gulliver's Travels is so misunderstood (https://www.bbc.com/culture/article/20261106-why-the-300-year-old-novel-gullivers-travels-is-so-misunderstood)
What is an Enigma machine? (https://www.christies.com/en/stories/collecting-guide-enigma-machines-79256fe652064942ad30c8167d4af51d)
Fable 5.2 and Jagged AGI [the first video is amazing] (https://www.oneusefulthing.org/p/fable-52-and-jagged-agi)
From the firehouse to a Bronx pawn shop, Steve Buscemi is a lifelong New Yorker (https://www.npr.org/2026/11/12/nx-s1-6032768/steve-buscemi-wild-horse-nine-pickpocket-new-york?shem=dsdf,sharefoc,agadiscoversdl,adpsc,,sh/x/discover/m1/4)
Scholar Dishes About Finding a Long-Lost Caravaggio Painting in Paris (https://www.artnews.com/art-news/news/lost-caravaggio-painting-rediscovered-paris-terzaghi-1234805289/)
Lost draft of Martin Luther King Jr.'s ‘I Have a Dream' speech rediscovered (https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2026/11/09/lost-draft-martin-luther-king-jrs-i-have-dream-speech-rediscovered/)
-Editor